Regarded as ‘one of the big hitters for catastrophic personal injury’, the London-based personal injury practice at Clyde & Co advises major insurance companies and corporate workplaces in complex fatal, cognitive, psychiatric, spinal cord, and polytraumatic injuries, in both UK and international jurisdictions. Practice co-chair Tony Cawley chiefly handles employer and public sector liability litigation, and is highlighted for his ‘strong and robust approach to claims’. Fellow co-chair Matthew Ford regularly litigates in large loss cases, which includes cognitive, spinal, chronic pain and fatal injury claims on behalf of insurers, brokers and corporate clients, areas that Claire Collins is also experienced in. Paula Jefferson specialises in sexual abuse and harassment cases, acting for educational organisations, health services, non-governmental organisations, faith organisations, and insurers, while Sharon Moohan's additional areas of expertise include child sexual abuse claims in educational and faith organisations. Nigel Lock advises on long-term and sensory deprivation injuries litigation, while Sharon MacArthur-Powell specialises in chronic pain and complex medical causation claims, especially among employers and public entities. Michelle Penn has left the firm.
Personal injury: defendant in London
Clyde & Co
Practice head(s):
Tony Cawley; Matthew Ford
Other key lawyers:
Claire Collins; Paula Jefferson; Matthew Ford; Nigel Lock; Sharon McArthur-Powell; Sharon Moohan; Sarah Murray-Smith; Philip Carney; Emily List; Edward Sainsbury; Paul Smith; Ben Jones
Testimonials
‘A variety of skills and talent.’
‘Tony Cawley and Matthew Ford – incredibly experienced litigators with a strong and robust approach to claims. Paul Smith and Claire Collins are also standouts.’
‘One of the big hitters for catastrophic personal injury insurance litigation, offering excellent value for money.’
Key clients
Admiral Insurance
Affinity Water
Ageas
AIG
AIM Mutual
Akzo Nobel Group
Allianz (Fraud)
Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty
Allianz Insurance
Arch Insurance
Armour
Aspen
Aviva
AXA Group
AXA XL
Balfour Beatty
Barclays Bank
Barry Nilsson Lawyers
Berkshire Hathaway Group
Bentley
Berkley Homes
Bloor Homes
Boparan
Bouygues
Bradford MBC
British Car Auctions
British Land
Broadspire (Crawfords)
Builders Direct
Capita
Care UK
Carlsberg
Catalina
Center Parcs
Chubb
City of Wolverhampton Council
CNA Hardy
Coca Cola Europacific Partners
Costa
Covea
Cucina
Derby City Council
Direct Line Group
Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council
Ecclesiastical
European Risk Insurance Company hf.
Fairmead Insurance(formerly L&G)
Faraday
First Port
Gallagher Bassett
Generali
Glen Dimplex
Grosvenor Casinos Limited
Hamilton Managing Agency Ltd
Hastings
HCA International
HDI
Herefordshire Council
Hiscox
Holts
Honeywell Group
Ikea
Insurance London Consortium (9 London Boroughs)
InterContinental Hotels Group
Intu
Ironshore
Jet2
Jet2 Holidays
Karro Food Group
Kent County Council
Kentucky Fried Chicken
Lastminute.com
Liberty Mutual Insurance
LV=
MAG
Manchester Underwriting
Marsh
Marshall of Cambridge
Matalan
Mecca Bingo Limited
Metrolink
MIB
Moto
MS Amlin
National Express
National Trust
New India Assurance
New Line
NFU Mutual
North Somerset Council
Northern Rail
Odeon
Olympic Holidays
One Insurance Limited
Peel Ports
Pen Underwriting plc
Persimmon
Plum Underwriting
Pro Global
Protector
QBE
QuestGates
Red Sea Holidays
Redrow
Regis
Ringway Jacobs
Riverstone
Royal Opera House
RSA
Ryder
Sainsburys
Sandals
Sedgwick
Shropshire Council
Sompo International
Subway
Telford & Wrekin Council
Tesco
Thames Valley Police
The Arcadia Group
The Davies Group
The Rank Group
TK Maxx
Tokio Marine
Towergate
Transdev
Travelers
Travelodge
Travis Perkins / Wickes
TSB
Vero Insurers
Vista Brokers
Wakefield MBC
Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council
Warburtons
Whitbread (Premier Inn, Brewers Fayre, Beefeater)
Wilko
Willis Towers Watson
Woodgate & Clark
XL Catlin Group
Zurich
Work highlights
DWF
A key port of call for defendant representation in group claims, traffic and workplace accidents, public sector liability and defective products, DWF's personal injury department is noted as ‘a first-rate team capable of handling cases of the highest value and complexity’. The team oversees a wide range of personal injury litigation, including severe cognitive, spinal and polytraumatic injuries, along with workplace injuries and multijurisdictional claims. Steven King co-heads the department with Mark Whittaker, both regarded as ports of call for public liability injuries, along with professional negligence. Claire Bowler regularly advises major private insurers in high-value traffic collision claims, typically involving large groups. Graham Dickinson frequently handles amputation, cognitive and spinal injury claims. Regarded as 'excellent on all fronts', Seema Bains holds over 20 years of experience in employer and public liability claims involving orthopaedic, brain and amputation injuries. Sara-Jane Eaton is recommended for international claims, especially for injuries incurred while travelling abroad. Dan Mitchell typically operates in cases pertaining to injuries within the logistics and passenger transport sector, while John Lezemore leads the department’s chronic pain claims team.
Practice head(s):
Steve King; Mark Whittaker
Other key lawyers:
Claire Bowler; Graham Dickinson; Seema Bains; Sara-Jane Eaton; Mark Whittaker; Dan Mitchell; John Lezemore; Rhys Sanchez; Jo Pizzala; Angela Hanmore; Caroline Sanders; Michelle Knapp; Daniel Jordan; Alastair Homan; Emma Clarke; Helen Walker; Thomas Magee; Emma Nicholls; Jamie Azim; Adela Carrasco
Testimonials
‘Excellent quality of service. Efficient with high quality of work.’
‘Seema Bains – first-class partner who is excellent on all fronts. Tony Cawley – highly committed to his clients with a very good level of service.’
‘The team dealing with chronic pain are particularly strong in their understanding of the medicine, the experts, and relationships with Counsel.’
Key clients
RSA
Aviva
The Markerstudy Group
QBE
Direct Line Group
Ms Amlin
Ageas
Tokio Marine Kiln
QIC
Antares Managing Agency Limited
LV
Generali
Van Ameyde (Uk) And Ireland
Ms Amlin
Hastings Direct
QBE
HDI Global
Mannheimer Versicherung Ag
Wuerttembergische Versicherung Ag
Gefion As (In Administration)
Ergo Hestia
Canopius
Allianz
First Central
Accredited Insurance Europe
Riverstone
Liberty
Work highlights
Kennedys
A ‘longstanding favourite of insurers’, the UK liability defence department at Kennedys is praised for its ‘incisive and robust advice.’ The team predominately acts for defendants in sophisticated, high-value disputes, working with local authorities, health services, public entities, and private and voluntary sector groups. Practice head Mark Burton is highlighted for his ‘tough but realistic approach to litigation’, which he brings to bear in claims concerning serious traffic collisions, sports injuries, amputations, and fatalities. Joe McManus handles multijurisdictional and higher circuit litigation. Antony French oversees maximum severity cognitive, spinal, polytrauma and chronic pain cases, while Charles Martin handles cognitive injury cases with an additional psychiatric injury component. Andrew Sheppard regularly represents public entities and local authorities, along with educational establishments such as schools and universities. Mark Dyson is highlighted for his ‘practical and exceptionally commercial’ advice, typically litigating on behalf of insurers and corporate risk groups in workplace violence, defective equipment and traffic collision litigation. Tom Walshaw handles public sector, abuse and complex liability claims, including bullying and harassment, public accidents, and cross-jurisdictional claims.
Practice head(s):
Claire Mulligan; Mark Burton
Other key lawyers:
Joe McManus; Antony French; Charles Martin; Tom Walshaw; Andrew Sheppard; Mark Dyson; Jo Kelly; Stephen Foster; Ben Appleton; Andrew Purdie; Ashley Mahon
Testimonials
‘A longstanding favourite of insurers who are often involved in some of the biggest cases around.’
‘Mark Burton is a star in this area, with a tough but realistic approach to litigation. Kennedys is able to draw upon a wider insurance and litigation practice to produce creative solutions.’
‘Mark Dyson and Ashley Mahon are proven and capable defendant personal injury solicitors. Their approach to handling litigated claims is practical and exceptionally commercial. They have an ability to commit to a robust course of action leading to quick settlements or solid maintainable defences. Where other lawyers see every instruction as an opportunity to churn fees, they refuse to cost build and will pursue the most economical route to conclusion for their clients.’
Key clients
Aviva
AA Motor Claims
Brit
Chubb
Acromas
Haven Insurance
World Rugby
Enstar
McDonalds
Work highlights
Herbert Smith Freehills LLP
The personal injury practice at Herbert Smith Freehills LLP pursues highly valuable and sophisticated catastrophic injury and fatality litigation valued at £1m at minimum, representing public entities, multinational corporations, and research institutions in novel personal injury claims resulting in polytraumatic and psychiatric, including workplace abuse and stress. Often advising on both domestic and multijurisdictional cases, David Bennett litigates in fatal accident claims, along with major psychiatric injuries stemming from workplaces.
Practice head(s):
David Bennett
Key clients
Diageo
Chevron
BAE
BP
TXU
Post Office
Arup
Work highlights
- Acted for Diageo in relation to claims for injuries arising from the alleged ingestion of thalidomide in the late 1950s/early 1960s.
- Acted for Chevron following the explosion at their refinery on 2 June 2011 which resulted in four fatalities, a serious personal injury and a number of stress and related claims.
- Acted for Post Office in relation to personal injury issues raised by former sub-postmasters and -postmistresses who are bringing claims against Post Office in connection with their internal computer system.
Weightmans LLP
Fielding ‘strength in depth across all areas’, the personal injury section of Weightmans LLP is adept in a diverse spectrum of catastrophic injury cases, spanning polytraumatic and psychiatric injuries incurred in sports businesses, workplaces, public entities, and, in particular, road collisions. The team fields both domestic and multijurisdictional experts, such as Simon Ball, who is notably experienced in French accident law. Catherine Kearney represents defendants in catastrophic brain, spine and amputation injuries, while Shaun Lavery is a port of call for tetraplegia, paraplegia and fatal injury claims. Steve Phillips holds over 30 years’ experience in occupational diseases and mesothelioma litigation, while Philip Tracey oversees product liability injuries and catastrophic harm incurred in the sports industry. Seva Singh advises defendants on maximum severity amputation, brain and spinal cord injury litigation.
Practice head(s):
Rob Williams; Will Quinn; Chris Ball; David Holt; Peter Forshaw; Jim Byard; Pamela Stevenson; Jim Bryant
Other key lawyers:
Kathryn Hinchley; Catherine Kearney; Shaun Lavery; Steve Philips; Seva Singh; Philip Tracey;
Testimonials
‘They are very strong all round outfit with strength in depth across all areas. Very much a one stop shop for serious injury matters of all types.’
‘Catherine Kearney is excellent. She is pragmatic, has excellent judgment and first rate client skills.’
‘A well established Defendant PI firm which handles many catastrophic claims with a fairness and expedition.’
‘Shaun Lavery – Weightmans is a young hugely able and industrious defence lawyer. He works very hard for his professional and insurer clients and does so delivering realistic and sensible advice timeously. He is fair minded in his approach to defending claims and has a knowledge and capability of a seasoned lawyer well beyond his year. He is an undoubted rising star. He is hugely dedicated and intellectually impressive.’
‘Very helpful, proactive and knowledgeable.’
‘W are very approachable, knowledgeable and I feel one of the best defendant insurance firms in the market. They are willing to go the extra mile in terms of service and added value.’
‘I have worked with Weightmans for many years. They quickly familiarised themselves with our business and seamlessly adapted their services to suit our needs. On an individual or team level, we have enjoyed a friendly, efficient and competitive service based on a considerable breadth of knowledge and experience. Clients requiring front-line legal claims services and complementary management support will find that Weightmans will enhance their business.’
‘Without exception Weightmans’ lawyers are friendly and professional – a subtle balance of expert clout and bon ami.’
Key clients
Zurich
Motor Insurers Bureau
AIG Europe
AXAXL Insurance
PwC (Chester Street Holdings)
Municipal Mutual Insurance
Tesco Underwriting
InterEurope AG Insurance
Covea Insurance
Octagon Insurance
Travelers Insurance Co
HDI Global
Hiscox Insurance
Esure Insurance
Hastings Direct
Berkshire Hathaway Speciality Insurance
Liberty Mutual
Markel Insurance
DCL Insurance
Tradex
Lidl Stores
Hundreds of Local Authorities and Police Authorities
Work highlights
- Acted in a claim where the court’s found in favour of both defendants and the Court’s analysis provides helpful guidance on the operation of the defence in the case of riding accidents.|
- Instructed to advise on a £22m+ case notable both in terms of liability and damages liability.
- Advised on an RTA in France where claimant claimed £15m+. The claim was issued pre-Brexit, and the applicable law was French law.
Browne Jacobson LLP
Browne Jacobson LLP‘s insurance and public risk team is recommended for its ‘exceptional client focus’, advising brokers, commercial insurers, public entities and policyholders on a range of high-severity injury disputes, including cognitive, spinal cord, industrial disease and fatal injury claims. The ‘tactically astute’ Kevin Lawson routinely advises insurers in sports, traffic accident and workplace injury claims. Other key figures include the head of the technical claims team James Fawcett, who handles high-value litigation on behalf of commercial and public sector actors.
Practice head(s):
Kevin Lawson; James Arrowsmith; Sarah Erwin-Jones; James Fawcett
Testimonials
‘Browne Jacobson stand out from the crowd for their exceptional client focus. As a result of this and the team’s ability always to think strategically they have an incredibly loyal and ever expanding client base.’
‘I have worked with a number of people in the PI team at Browne Jacobson and without exception they have been a pleasure to work with.’
‘Good team who are always available to discuss files – good sector knowledge.’
‘James Fawcett is a good lawyer with an excellent feel for litigation.’
Key clients
Hiscox
Municipal Mutual Insurance Limited
Marble Arch – Lexham Insurance Services
NHS Resolution
Zurich
Gallagher Bassett
Davies Group
Resolute
Norfolk County Council
EM LawShare
Work highlights
Keoghs LLP
Keoghs LLP‘s complex injury team fields ‘unrivalled experience across the full range value of claims’, handling mandates which require expertise in cognitive, spinal and amputation injury claims, injuries resulting in fatalities, and complex medical causation disputes. ‘Experienced, tough and dedicated’, Catherine Kober heads the London-based department, working with all manner of public and private sector defendants on liability and quantum disputes involving cognitive, spinal, amputation and fatal claims. Practice co-chair Phillip Bratt advises defendant insurers in maximum severity injury litigation, including brain, spinal and amputation injuries for adults and pediatrics.
Practice head(s):
Catherine Kober; Phill Bratt
Testimonials
‘A large spread of lawyers across the country. They still manage to deliver an excellent service despite being a very large firm.’
‘Catherine Kober is first-rate. She is very experienced, tough and dedicated.’
‘Unrivalled experience across the full range (value) of claims.’
Key clients
Travelers Insurance
Tesco Insurance
Motor Insurers’ Bureau
Liverpool Victoria Insurance Limited
Faraday Insurance
Direct Line Group
ERS Insurance
Zurich Insurance
Capulus Insurance
Pen Underwriting
Work highlights
- Advised London Market insurer on a £25m traumatic brain injury claim.
- Defended MIB against a £3.5m traumatic brain injury claim.
Harrison Clark Rickerbys
Regarded by one client as an 'amazing firm of lawyers with depth across the board', Harrison Clark Rickerbys is well versed in a range of matters, including terror attacks, workplace injuries, and other civil claims. Practice co-chair Jonathan Edwards - 'hugely experienced and unflappable in high pressure situations' - is noted for the breadth of his capabilities, which encompass claims arising from employers', management, motor, cyber, and property liability policies. 'An excellent strategic thinker with great judgment and intuition', fellow co-chair Leanne Conisbee focuses on employer's liability and public liability incidents concerning serious injury and fatalities.
Practice head(s):
Jonathan Edwards; Leanne Conisbee
Testimonials
‘In the personal injury team, the ability to grasp the issues and work effectively and efficiently to seek the best solutions for the client sets this firm apart from their competitors.’
‘Leanne Conisbee is excellent. Her expertise and knowledge in defendant personal injury and regulatory issues is superb. Clients feel at ease and are reassured. She is calm and organised; she never needs to be chased for updates. Our reputation rests on the legal team we use for our liability book and we can be firmly assured of this with Leanne and HCR. ’
‘HCR is an outstanding firm. The partners are exceptional in their leadership and experience offering insurers an outstanding service at competitive rates. The quality of their work is uniformly high and they always add real value to their cases. The associates are hard working and combine strong forensic attention to detail with strong client care skills. As a firm, they offer everything that a Defendant insurer could possibly want.’
‘Jonathan Edwards is hugely experienced and unflappable in high pressure situations. He is extremely skilled in uncovering key points of evidence and invariably succeeds in cases others would regard as unwinnable.’
‘Leanne Conisbee is a tremendous asset in every case. She handles huge and difficult cases with aplomb. She combines excellent legal knowledge and has outstanding client care skills. Her opponents respect her judgment and she would always be my first choice in any catastrophic injury case.’
‘Amazing firm of lawyers with depth across the board. From HSE prosecutions, dispute resolution or standard litigation matters HCR Law are the firm to choose. Their attention to detail, our clients brand protection and the exceptional results they achieve is the reason to choose HCR Law. They have supported our FTSE 100 clients and Corporate clients with challenging matters and act promptly to respond to authorities and lawyers to achieve exceptional results. ’
‘Strong emerging contenders in a busy market. I have done and continue to do many heavy cases for this team in health and safety. Well resourced, significant legal and business acumen delivering for their clients each time. ’
‘Jonathan Edwards – a real market leader in insurance backed cases of signficance. He knows exactly what the client wants and exactly how to deliver. Leanne Connisbee – ahead of the game in all her work – an excellent strategic thinker with great judgment and intuition. ’
Work highlights
Hill Dickinson LLP
Recommended for its ‘excellent market knowledge’, Hill Dickinson LLP chiefly advises defendants in marine sector related litigation, handling multijurisdictional claims arising in maritime and port settings. The team's workload regularly involves catastrophic injuries, sexual abuse, industrial disease, psychiatric injuries and fatal claims among crews, passengers and port employees. Noted for his expertise in marine, ports, offshore and maritime leisure travel and holiday disputes, practice head John Caddies has considerable experience in fatal and catastrophic injury claims, as well as industrial maritime diseases. Janet McWhinney primarily acts for NHS Resolution and Medical Protection for claims involving severe brain and spinal injuries. Javed Ali is a frequent litigator for claims pertaining to passenger rights and cruise line injuries. Praised for her ‘unparalleled professionalism’, Sarah Barnes has over 10 years of experience advising major port operators, shipping companies, tour and cruise lines, and other maritime businesses.
Practice head(s):
John Caddies
Other key lawyers:
Janet McWhinney; Javed Ali; Sarah Barnes
Testimonials
‘The broadest scope to deal with the intricacies of travel law issues. Willing to tailor invoices to separate VAT from the responsibility of the overseas priomary client. Willing to discuss niggling side-issues off the clock.’
‘Sarah Barnes treats clients like friends, but always with unparalleled professionalism when required.’
‘The team is highly skilled and are not only experts on the legal issues, they are able to see the commercial aspect, which is sometimes most important to ensuring the correct resolution to a file.’
‘John Caddies and Sarah Barnes have been my go to people for any UK Personal injury claims for several years. They are approachable and will happily discuss issues, prior to their involvement and even provide advice on issues that might even result in their involvement not being necessary.’
‘Excellent market knowledge, concise advise and obtains good resolutions.’
Key clients
Associated British Ports
Saga Cruises
Seatruck Ferries
DFDS
Royal Caribbean Cruises
P&O Ferries
Red Funnel Ferries
UK P&I Club
West of England P&I Club
Generali
Maersk Shipping Company
Maersk Offshore (Guernsey) Limited
Viking Ocean Cruises
Shipowners Mutual P&I Club
RSA
Gard P&I Club
Britannia P&I Club
Swedish P&I Club
Steamship P&I Club
London P&I Club
Louis Hotels
MSC Crociere
NorthStandard P&I Club
American Steamship Owners P&I Club
Svitzer Marine Limited
Assuranceforeningen SKULD (GJENSIDIG) P&I Club
BP Shipping Limited
CNA Hardy
Work highlights
Keystone Law
Representing a diverse array of defendants, Keystone Law works with a number of local authorities and public entities - including employers and insurers - in both traumatic and catastrophic physical injuries and psychiatric claims. Cordelia Rushby acts for defendants in cases where liability is in dispute, representing manufacturers and local authorities in employer and transport injury disputes, while Steven Conway is a port of call for cases involving public infrastructure, highways and other circumstances where local authorities are involved in injury litigation.
Other key lawyers:
Steven Conway; Cordelia Rushby
Testimonials
‘Keystone Law are often used by our insurers when we have some more difficult personal injury issues.’
‘Cordelia Rushby is an outstanding solicitor in this area. She is very sensible and tells us as it is, gives clear advice and finds good solutions to difficult problems. She also doesn’t give up, keeps things moving forward and follows up if information is not forthcoming. She has great knowledge and experience.’
‘When we appoint Keystone Law we know we are going to receive the best support and guidance there is to be had.’
‘Steven Conway of Keystone Law is without doubt the go-to defendant solicitor for any complex injury/damage claims where the alleged incident has occurred on the public highway. His knowledge and expertise is second to none, instilling confidence that any defence will be appropriate and robust. Steven understands what we need, and always makes us feel he is part of our team, not just an external contractor being paid for a job.’
Key clients
Allianz Global
Work highlights
RPC
The general liability department at RPC fields ‘true industry experts’, with a particular focus on workplace injuries occurring in the media, leisure and construction industries. Department head Gavin Reese, commended for his ‘excellent negotiation skills’, has more than 30 years of experience representing insurance companies and corporate clients in fatal and catastrophic injury disputes. Fiona Hahlo operates in both psychiatric and physical injury claims, including cognitive injuries, while Thom Lumley specialises in amputation cases. Mamata Dutta is a port of call for psychiatric injuries, inquests, and complex polytrauma cases.
Practice head(s):
Gavin Reese
Other key lawyers:
Fiona Hahlo; Mamata Dutta; Thom Lumley
Testimonials
‘A boutique operator by comparison to some of the giants at work in the insurance sector, but therefore able to provide a very bespoke and personalised service.’
‘Mamata Dutta – a very gritty lawyer who can read risk and often gets early and commercial settlements. Fiona Hahlo – a brilliant lawyer whose case preparation is first class.’
‘Having worked extensively with the PI team at RPC this year on a complicated multi defendant case, Fiona Hahlo stands out in particular. She was incredibly adept at understanding the issues in the case and in dealing with a somewhat uncooperative insured client. She was also an excellent negotiator and achieved a very good commercial result for the client shortly prior to trial.’
‘Well respected full service defendant team. Has the strength and depth to deal with the entire spectrum of litigated cases in this arena – including catastrophic and complex cases.’
‘Gavin Reese holds excellent negotiation skills – always gets favourable results in JSMs and mediations. Well regarded in the insurance sector.’
‘A team combined with true industry experts.’
‘Thom Lumley – a trusted advisor to insurers, large corporates, SMEs and local authorities alike.’
‘Gavin Reese, Mamata Dutta and Fiona Hahlo provide strength in depth and can act across the board from the regulatory aspect of serious injury cases as well as dealing with the civil claims. Equally adept at both.’
Work highlights
- Acted for French cycling organisation and its insurer in connection with the death of a participant in an elite amateur cycle event.
- Acted for an arboricultural company that had carried out a survey of a tree that fell on an individual, causing catastrophic injuries.
- Instructed by the defendant’s insurer to investigate a claim and advise on policy coverage and quantum, following a fall from a ladder causing spinal damage.