The ‘consistently professional and approachable’ Carson McDowell teams are well known for providing clients with a full range of matters. Roger McMillan and Jacqueline McAleese head the clinical negligence defence department. McMillan is a specialist in defending medical professionals in alleged misdiagnosis and delay in diagnosis claims in the High Court, while McAleese focuses on defending complex cervical and expedited cancer cases. Catherine Carton and Cathal O’Neill, who are both ‘very approachable and very engaged’ lead the insurance personal injury team. Carton is active on both employer’s liability and public liability matters, while O’Neill is well versed in high-value asbestos claims.
Personal injury and clinical negligence: defendant in Northern Ireland
Carson McDowell
Practice head(s):
Roger McMillan; Jacqueline McAleese; Catherine Carton; Cathal O’Neill
Testimonials
I consider Carson McDowell as one of the two top teams in Northern Ireland. All the members of the team are out of the top drawer both in terms of intellect and work ethic. They retain the best experts in the relevant fields with other preparatory work to include analysis being carried out to the very best standards.’
The individuals with whom I have most contact are Roger McMillan, Jacqueline McAleese and Anna Haines- Smyth. All are clear leaders in the field.’
‘This is a large and well regarded team with great resources and considerable technical experience and skills which means they are in huge demand.’
‘I have dealt with Carson McDowell over ten years and have found their team to be consistently professional and approachable. They provide clear and pragmatic advice on complex issues and have achieved some very good results for insurer clients.’
‘Catherine Caton deals with our higher value and complex litigation and provides detailed advice on those cases. She is commercially aware but very robust where needed, which has led to excellent results.’
‘All cases in which I instruct Carson McDowell are handled by the exceptional Catherine Carton. Catherine’s grasp of my principal clients’ requirements is very strong. She provides good, commercially aware advice with the focus on protecting the client’s interests. Communications are timely and refreshingly free from ‘legalese’ while procedural matters are dealt with efficiently and accurately.’
‘Carson McDowell are leaders in Clinical Negligence. They are my go-to for any Northern Ireland clinical negligence claims. They stand apart in the way they invest a lot of time getting to know the client and understanding their expectations.’
‘Catherine Carton and Cathal O’Neill are very approachable and very engaged. Open to discussions and training advice along with providing good results and feedback on defended cases. Rarely do we have to chase for updates as we are continually updated throughout the claim.
Key clients
The Medical Protection Society
Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland
Dental Protection Limited
National Pharmaceutical Association
Association of Optometrists
Beazley Group
WRB Underwriting
Personal Injury – Defendant
AIA Australia
Belfast Harbour Commissioners
Kelly Adjusters
Travelers Insurance
Axis Capital
Enstar
Sedgwick
Faraday Insurance
Riverstone Insurance
Davies Casualty/Garwyn
TT Club/Thomas Miller Claims Management
Crawford Loss Adjustors/Broadspire
Northern Ireland Electricity Networks Ltd
Beale & Co
McLarens
Stena Line
QBE
Work highlights
Clyde & Co LLP
The Clyde & Co Belfast team specialises in offering legal services to the insurance sector, including indemnity issues, and defending claims. Cormac Fitzpatrick heads the department and often leads cases which involve severe injuries, including injuries to the brain, abdominal area, and spine. Graeme Moore excels at defending claims concerning health and safety executive investigations, while Michelle McCullough often acts on insurance litigations concerning traffic accidents. Legal director Naomi Campbell continues to act for one of the world’s largest insurers in personal injury cases.
Practice head(s):
Cormac Fitzpatrick
Other key lawyers:
Graeme Moore; Michelle McCullough; Naomi Campbell
Work highlights
DAC Beachcroft
DAC Beachcroft is an international firm which services many leading insurers and underwriters worldwide. Sean McGahan leads the 'highly efficient' and 'always approachable' Belfast team. McGahan specialises in both short-tail and long-tail disease claims. Aisling Mellon heads the motor team and often leads on claims concerning high value traffic accidents. Catriona McCorry is the key contact for clinical negligence, while Louise Butler is well versed in casualty injury claims. Kevin O'Hagan specialises in assisting clients with personal injury claims which involve regulatory issues. Legal director Amanda McClimond is a strong performer in insurance panel clinical negligence matters.
Practice head(s):
Sean McGahan
Other key lawyers:
Aisling Mellon; Catriona McCorry; Louise Butler; Kevin O’Hagan; Amanda McClimond
Testimonials
‘Very approachable and knowledgeable, you feel like you’re in safe hands with them.’
‘Aisling Mellon is always available to support our teams and we have every confidence in the advice Aisling provides. It’s clear that Aisling is an expert in the field, understand the opponents, and is fully up to speed on market developments.’
‘We have been dealing with DAC Beachcroft for many years and have seen the development of the practice over this time. They are a very slick operation with expertise in all areas of defence litigation. Their technical knowledge is excellent.’
Key clients
Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance LTD
NFU Mutual Insurance UK
Northern Ireland Water Limited
Sabre Insurance Company Limited
Admiral Insurance
Riverstone International
Resolute Management
Med Pro
Corvelia
Amet insurance
Work highlights
- Resolved a significant scarring case with an estimated value of £175,000 damages and costs inclusive for £97,500 damages and costs which represented a 45% saving on the potential value for a motor insurer.
- Resolved a complex personal injury claim for a leading motor insurer for £260,000 damages and costs, which represented a 52% saving on the claim’s potential value.
- Securing the withdrawal of a mesothelioma claim worth over £280,000 in damages and costs by tracing historical liability evidence in relation to company liquidated decades ago, for a long tail insurance provider.
Kennedys
Kennedys is an international commercial law firm which specialises in insurance defendant work. The Belfast office offers clinical negligence work for a large number of medical professionals, such as chiropractors, aestheticians, and plastic surgeons. Practice head Amanda Wylie, ‘one of the leading figures in the local professional negligence and large loss sector’ specialises in personal injury litigation, including matters at the High Court level, or cross-jurisdictional in nature. Wylie is often assisted by associate Megan Boyd with ‘meticulous preparation and attention to detail’. Senior associate Ian Martindale is adept in handling complex special loss claims, while senior associate Gareth McKee regularly assists insurers in professional negligence and industrial disease matters.
Practice head(s):
Amanda Wylie
Other key lawyers:
Megan Boyd; Ian Martindale; Gareth McKee; James Ferrin
Testimonials
‘Kennedys Belfast is one of the original entrants of a major UK firm into the local market. As such, they are among the market leaders in this area with a strong team who marry tenacious defence of their client’s interests with a sound commercial and pragmatic approach.’
‘Senior partner, Amanda Wylie, is one of the leading figures in the local professional negligence and large loss sector and a tenacious advocate on behalf of her clients.’
‘Amanda Wylie is the undisputed boss who seems to manage to be on top of every single file in the office.
Work highlights
Tughans
The Tughans insurance and disputes team, led by Kathy McGillie, has a litigation practice which is described as ‘second to none’. McGillie, an expert in health and safety regulatory investigations and related litigation, is a key contact for insurers and large corporates. McGillie is often supported by Pauline Walker, a legal director who is experienced in employer and public liability matters which involve workplace accidents. The ‘very friendly and approachable’ Neil Smyth often represents insurers in defending claims concerning fraud, traffic accidents, and public liability. Other noteworthy individuals include Andrew Anthony; Alistair Wilson; and associate director Francesca Glynn.
Practice head(s):
Kathy McGillie
Other key lawyers:
Neil Smyth; Pauline Walker; Andrew Anthony; Alastair Wilson; Francesca Glynn
Testimonials
‘Tughans are a great practice. Their staff make them a truly unique practice. They are a “one stop shop” for any legal need you have, whether personal or commercial. This is what differentiates Tughans from their competitors.’
‘Neil Smyth is a top-class solicitor. As he is dual qualified, when we have clients trading on both sides of the border, Neil is ideally placed to deal with their legal matters. He has also has great principals and is a straight pragmatic talker.’
‘Neil Smyth is a very competent solicitor with strong technical knowledge. He is extremely approachable and he looks after all of his clients in an exemplary manner.’
‘Tughans have a very proactive team who are very proactive in dealing with cases.’
‘Neil Smyth isery engaging with clients, always available for discussions and always answer the phone.’
‘Over over the last twenty years, Tughans are the standout practice that I have worked with. Always prompt with replies and queries, very accessible, and have a wide range of talent and expertise. The litigation team are second to none.’
‘I have worked with Neil Smyth for approximately 15 years, he is very friendly and approachable. His technical support and advice are excellent. I have recommended him to many clients and he has never lets us down.’
Work highlights
DWF
The healthcare and insurance team at DWF advises insurers and self-insured businesses across a wide variety of cases, like catastrophic injury, fraud, occupational health, among other areas. The Belfast team is supported by the firm’s wider UK network, with offices in cities including London, Edinburgh, and Newcastle. The practice is jointly headed by Laura Menary and Mark Johnston. Menary, ‘courteous, responsive, and with excellent attention to detail’ is often active on misdiagnoses and delay in diagnosis clinical negligence matters.
Practice head(s):
Laura Menary; Mark Johnston
Testimonials
‘A strong firm in Northern Ireland locally mixing local traditions with the resources of a large UK law firm.’
‘Great team, full of talented solicitors who are excellent at managing their caseloads. ’
‘Mark Johnston leads from the front. A highly organised and extremely pragmatic solicitor, who is excellent to work with.’
Key clients
Allianz
Axa
Aviva
RSA
QBE
Riverstone
Hiscox
Gallagher Bassett
Covea
LV=
Amlin
NFU Mutual
British Telecoms Plc
Ageas
Liberty
DLG
Amazon
Markerstudy
Enterprise Rentacar
XS Direct
Canopius
Sedgwick
Hastings
Admiral
Travelers
Medical Protection Society
Dental Protection
NHS Resolution
Argo Group
Optical Express
Work highlights
Keoghs LLP
Backed by its UK network, Keoghs LLP Belfast advises insurers with a wide range of matters involving road traffic accidents, breach of contracts, and catastrophic injuries. Practice head Victoria McLean, a ‘very measured and a reassuring presence’, specialises in traffic accident claims which result in complex injuries. Megan McBrien, having previously practised as a barrister, regularly acts in employer and public liability litigations. Rachel Keenan has recently been working on fatal road accident cases. In January 2024, McBrien and Keenan were both promoted to partner.
Practice head(s):
Victoria McLean
Other key lawyers:
Rachel Keenan; Megan McBrien; Edel McCullagh
Testimonials
‘All round knowledge and ability to diversify types of work handled. Super knowledge of local market.’
‘Victoria McClean is a solicitor at the top of her game. Brings strong technical knowledge and an ability to quickly grasp the issues at play. Very measured and a reassuring presence for brokers and clients alike.’
‘Victoria McLean and Edel McCullough kept me up-to-date on all cases involving my clients and provided an excellent service. Always approachable and willing to help.’
Work highlights
Arthur Cox Belfast
The dispute resolution team at Arthur Cox Belfast provides legal representation for insurance companies or corporate clients across various personal injury cases, encompassing employers’ liability, public liability, and occupiers’ liability claims. The ‘very responsible and knowledgeable’ Chris Ritchie leads the team. Ritchie specialises in areas including hearing loss and product liability claims.
Practice head(s):
Chris Ritchie
Testimonials
‘The team’s expertise encompasses both personal injury and health and safety, which is a useful combination.’
‘Chris Ritchie is a pleasure to work with. Very responsive and knowledgeable. ’
Key clients
Rapid Granulator AB
Northern Ireland Housing Executive
Tetratech
Courtaulds Textiles
UIA Insurance
ZimmerBiomet
Travelers Insurance
Education Authority of NI
Medtronic
Crossbow Optical
Napier Solicitors
The Napier Solicitors litigation department provides legal services for the education, public authority, and religious sectors, boasting a strong reputation in these fields. The department is jointly led by managing partner Joseph Napier and senior solicitor Claire Wilson. Napier's focus areas include motor, public, and employer liability cases, as well as a niche in the educational and religious sectors. Meanwhile, Wilson brings her experience in handling personal injury litigation to the team.
Practice head(s):
Joseph Napier; Claire Wilson