Hall Of Fame

Commercial litigation in Wales

Acuity Law

The 'partner-led' team at Acuity Law provides a 'commercial service' to local, UK-wide and international corporates across a broad swathe of commercial litigation, ranging from shareholder and commercial contract disputes to public procurement and construction matters. Clients also benefit from access to a range of useful internal products, including Litigation Funding Assist, which affords clients the opportunity to achieve favourable rates via the firm's arrangements with various litigation funders. Swansea-based partner Hugh Hitchcock brings a high degree of commerciality to the table as a result of his vast experience handling both corporate and media-related disputes and is noted for his 'practical, pragmatic and pugnacious' approach. 'Brilliant in the detail and strategy', Cardiff-based Aisha Wardell co-heads the team alongside Hitchcock and is noted for her 'calm and considered approach', including in the context of arbitration proceedings.

Practice head(s):

Hugh Hitchcock; Aisha Wardell


Other key lawyers:

Jon Hill; Janice Powell; Huw Roffe; Jared Ursell; Martin Cox


Testimonials

They provide a partner-led and commercial service.’

‘Hugh Hitchcock is practical, pragmatic and pugnacious.’

Hugh Hitchcock has a bright mind and is determined to win for his clients.’

Aisha Wardell has a calm and considered approach that puts both the client and opposition at ease. Brilliant in the detail and strategy to achieve favourable resolution.’

Aisha Wardell provides technically sophisticated advice.’

Key clients

Corinthian Brands Limited


Helix Securities LLP


BraceUrself Ltd


Quantum Actuarial LLP


Remedy Healthcare Solutions Limited


Portman Healthcare Limited


Au Vodka Limited


Loches Capital Limited


Grant Thornton UK LLP


Premier Forest Group


Loches Capital Limited


Community Homes of Intensive Care and Education Limited


Monroe Partners Limited


Silva Brothers Logistics Limited


Impact Innovation & Growth Services Limited


IRIS Software Group Limited


Work highlights


  • Advised BraceUrself in its claim against NHS England concerning a challenge to the award of a contract for orthodontic service.
  • Advised HR Investors group, 26 individuals and companies against 12 defendants, including two current and former solicitors. Claims include unlawfully establishing and operating unregulated collective investment schemes, misrepresentation, and deceit.
  • Advised Red and Yellow Limited and R&Y NL Limited on a dispute arising from a joint venture agreement in relation to the development of quality extra care accommodation.

Blake Morgan LLP

The 'very professional' team at Blake Morgan LLP provides 'high-quality advice' to private and public sector clients across a myriad disputes. Lee Fisher takes the lead on much of the private sector work, both across corporate/shareholder litigation, as well as IP matters, including on the enforcement of patents and trade marks. Joanne Thompson co-heads the team alongside Fisher and is best-known for her procurement defence work for contracting bodies in challenges made by unsuccessful bidders. She is also one of many in the team who have considerable experience handling major public inquiries, including her work for NHS England in the Covid-19 inquiry. Sarah Whittle is also pivotal to the firm's success for public sector clients (particularly within the health sector), including as it relates to public procurement and judicial review challenges. Joanna Corbett-Simmons maintains a good balance of public and private sector instructions and 'has a very bright future ahead of her'. 

 

Practice head(s):

Lee Fisher; Joanne Thompson


Other key lawyers:

Sarah Whittle; Joanna Corbett-Simmons; Trish D’Souza; Daniel Taylor


Testimonials

The team is very professional and provides high-quality advice.’

The excellent Joanne Thompson is an experienced procurement litigator.’

Joanna Corbett-Simmons has a very bright future ahead of her.’

Key clients

NHS England


Andrew McCarthy/Garrison Barclay


Cardiff Council


Welsh Blood Service


Welsh Language Commissioner


Norvill


KSY Juice Blends Limited


Capital Green Recycling


Swansea University


Welsh Ministers


Work highlights


  • Acting for NHS England in a landmark case in the Court of Appeal concerning the issue of when an error made in a procurement process is “sufficiently serious” to warrant an award in damages (Braceurself v NHS England).
  • Advising NHS England in respect of the Covid Inquiry.
  • Acting for KSY Juice Blends UK Limited in proceedings against Citrusuco GmbH (one of the two largest global orange juice producers) in a £1.2m breach of contract claim.

Eversheds Sutherland

Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP comprises of 'good legal and litigation all-rounders', which is reflected in the scope of work handled for private and public sector clients, running the gamut from financial services and corporate/shareholder disputes, public procurement and judicial review challenges. 'Responsive, pragmatic, down-to-earth and to the point', Richard Pitt is at the forefront of the office's commercial litigation work for clients in core firmwide industry sectors, including transport, IT and renewables. In addition, alongside Helen Rowland ('good judgement and a very safe pair of hands'), he heads up the office's public procurement offering, which is particularly skilled at representing claimants in bringing challenges in failed bids. Luisa Gibbons has a core focus on public sector matters, including for education institutions in contractual disputes and judicial review proceedings. Under the leadership of Gareth Vowles , the office also excels in handling financial services-related litigation and aided by very effective legal technology solutions, the team excels in defending banks in document intensive mass tort litigation, including as it relates to mis-selling of financial products.

Practice head(s):

Richard Pitt; Gareth Vowles; Robert Philips; Alison Short; Glenn Newberry


Other key lawyers:

Helen Rowland; Tom Black; Wayne Davies; Luisa Gibbons; James Coleman; Lindsey Caddy; Daniel Gilligan


Testimonials

‘Good legal and litigation all-rounders, excellent with clients and at understanding where the client is trying to get to.’

Richard Pitt is responsive, pragmatic, down-to-earth and to the point, he provides meaningful advice that understands my business and the specific landscape within which it operates.’

Helen Rowland – good judgement and a very safe pair of hands for difficult issues.’

Key clients

Air Liquide Healthcare Limited


Optima Healthcare Limited


The Stationery Office


Network Rail


Consultant Connect


Lumon Risk Management Limited


Close Brothers Limited


Marelli


Serious Fraud Office


Equality and Human Rights Commission


Agents Mutual


EDF Energy


Dwr Cymru/Welsh Water


Teaching Regulatory Agency


Work highlights


Geldards LLP

Leveraging its longstanding and impressive overarching public sector ties, including for the Welsh government, Geldards LLP's litigation team is regularly engaged in some of the highest-profile matters in the country. In this context, as well as continuing to represent the Welsh Ministers in a high-profile competition law claim relating to a drug to treat high blood pressure, the firm also acts for the Ministers at the high-profile infected blood inquiry. Jonathan Griffiths is at the forefront of much of the public sector work, and is noted for his public procurement and judicial review prowess, in particular. On the private sector front, Michael Evans excels in handling commercial contract, shareholders disputes, debt recovery and contentious insolvency matters. Team head Paul Hopkins maintains a strong practice in the public sector, as well as handling a considerable amount of broader commercial litigation for corporate clients.

Practice head(s):

Paul Hopkins


Other key lawyers:

Jonathan Griffiths; Michael Evans; Gosia Evans; Madeleine Jordan; Rhys Thompson


Testimonials

‘The team is responsive, knowledgeable and easy to deal with.’

Key clients

The Welsh Ministers (i.e. Welsh Government)


Propel Finance No 1 Limited


Natural Resources Wales


Celsa UK Group


Resource Limited and related companies (incl Euro Commercials (South Wales) Limited and Isoclad Limited)


TBD (Owen Holland) Limited


Mr Richard Hayward and Bolwell & Hayward Limited


Jardine Norton Limited


Mr Simon Wright and Corinthian Group and related companies


AC Gill Limited


Velindre University NHS Trust


A F Blakemore & Son Ltd


Work highlights


  • Represent The Welsh Ministers and NHS in Wales in pursuing a substantial competition law claim against Servier SAS and others in relation to the drug Perindopril.
  • Advised Mr Richard Leighton Hayward, an established property portfolio owner and developer in South Wales and his offshore company Guinevere Holdings Limited in respect of a complex £2.4m claim brought against them by another offshore company, Grenda Investments Limited (with whom our clients had business dealings) and its solicitors, Richard Slade and Company Ltd.
  • Representing the Welsh Ministers at the Infected Blood Inquiry. This is an independent statutory inquiry into the use of infected blood. It examines why men, women and children in the UK were given infected blood and/or infected blood products; the impact on their families; how the authorities (including the government) responded; the nature of any support provided following infection; questions of consent; and whether there was a cover-up.

Hugh James

Drawing upon 'incredible knowledge and expertise', both in relation to the substantive law and the procedural rules, Hugh James provides 'pragmatic, commercially minded and robust' advice to public sector, private sector and not-for-profit clients across a wide-range of high-stakes contractual and commercial disputes, as well as niche areas concerning professional negligence and defamation. Team head Richard Locke has strong and well-established ties with numerous major regional heavyweights, including Welsh Water, which he recently successfully represented as an interested party in a judicial review surrounding a decision made by Cardiff Council to grant planning permission in respect of a sewage pumping station and associated surface water extraction scheme. The 'tenacious' Tracey Singlehurst-Ward leverages 'strong legal knowledge and excellent strategic insight' to good effect for clients seeking resolution of often highly complex issues relating to IP, media, sport and defamation. The 'very bright' Abigail Flanagan has 'excellent knowledge of the law and is brilliant with clients', which she effectively represents in relation to pensions and professional negligence matters, and core contractual/ shareholders disputes, including complex litigation involving injunctive relief.

Practice head(s):

Richard Locke


Other key lawyers:

Tracey Singlehurst-Ward; Abigail Flanagan; Bethan Hartland


Testimonials

Very strong all round litigation team – very reasonable fees given the level of service and commitment and a very comprehensive offering.’

They are pragmatic, commercially minded and robust.’

They have incredible knowledge and expertise and deal with clients with such respect and empathy.’

Abigail Flanagan – very bright, excellent knowledge of the law and is brilliant with clients.’

Tracey Singlehurst-Ward – superb and tenacious litigator with strong legal knowledge and excellent strategic insight.’

Key clients

NatWest


British Boxing Board of Control Limited


Welsh Government


Bridgend County Borough Council


City and Council of Swansea


Cardiff County Council


Llais Cymru


Cardiff Blues Limited


Rockwool Limited


Development Bank of Wales


Natural Resources Wales


Welsh Water


Work highlights


  • Successfully defended Welsh Water in judicial review proceedings.
  • Defending SJJ System Services Ltd, a commercial engineering group, in proceedings brought by Weiss group companies for alleged infringement of intellectual property rights and breach of contract.
  • Acted for Involegal LLP in pursuing a claim valued at over £17m against BLM LLP (solicitors) in professional negligence.

Morgan LaRoche

With a its main base in Swansea and increasingly active from the firm's thriving Carmarthen office, the 'superb' practice at Morgan LaRoche punches well-above-its weight, regularly 'dealing with difficult and heavy cases', both locally and throughout the UK. A litigator of 'long and broad experience', Jason Williams reflects the varied caseload of the firm as a whole and 'his experience across different fields makes him an imaginative and flexible solver of problems'. Llyr Davies, who co-heads the team with Williams from the firm's Carmarthen office, provides 'no-nonsense, pragmatic and cost-effective advice' to West Walian clients often in the medium of Welsh. As well as his expertise in relation to shareholder, company and partnership disputes, Davies has also generated an excellent relationship with local professional services companies which continues to generate a significant amount of contentious insolvency work, as well as a growing amount of contentious probate matters. In Swansea, the 'extremely hardworking' Gemma Thomas continues to thrive, producing 'fantastic work that is both clear and detailed'; she recently worked with Williams on a successful hearing before the Court of Appeal, having herself led on the previous successful appearance in the High Court for the claimant regarding the inflated payment of a company in reliance of false warranties and fraudulent misrepresentations. Ashley Davies 'provides clear and precise commercial advice' for defendants and claimants in relation to shareholder disputes, debt recovery and professional negligence, while at an associate level the 'up and coming' Robert Davies also continues to impress across a range of corporate and insolvency disputes.

Practice head(s):

Jason Williams; Llyr Davies


Other key lawyers:

Gemma Thomas; Ashley Davies; Robert Davies


Testimonials

The team displays strength-in-depth and can draw on a wealth of wide and deep experience in a number of different fields.’

A superb practice, punching well above its weight, and dealing with difficult and heavy cases.’

‘Really strong team for Wales and wider-UK focused commercial litigation.

Key clients

Cawdor Cars (Newcastle Emlyn) Limited


Hafan Cymru


Llanelec Precision Engineering Company Limited


MDW (Holdings) Limited


Neath Port Talbot (Recycling) Limited


Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council


Mon Motor Group


G Filer Engineering Limited


AMP Clean Energy


Colosseum Dental UK Limited


Swansea Building Society


Pelenna Property Partnership Limited


Principality Building Society


Nemo Personal Finance Ltd


Blackhills Caravan Sales Ltd


Genesis Property Management Ltd


Work highlights


  • Successfully representing Neath Port Talbot (Recycling) Limited in a breach of contract claim concerning two substantial waste management and disposal contracts, including post-judgment enforcement via a shareholder company who took assignment of the Judgment Debt.
  • Successfully representing MDW (Holdings) Limited in a claim for breach of warranty, deceit and fraudulent misrepresentation concerning the sale of shares in a waste management/disposal company under a Share Purchase Agreement.
  • Representing Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council in post-judgment enforcement proceedings including a successful application for a freezing injunction against five defendants, maintaining the freezing injunction against all defendants until conclusion including successfully defending an application to dismiss the freezing injunction, pursuing Insolvency Act applications including under section 423.

Berry Smith

Acting on an ad-hoc standalone basis, as well as being to leverage strong institutional relationships, Berry Smith displays 'strong commercial acumen and excellent analytical skills’ on behalf of public, private and third sector clients across a wide range of commercial litigation/contractual disputes. Nick Parker has a strong grounding in corporate disputes (including director's disqualification proceedings) as well as public procurement matters, work which he combines with a well-established mediation practice. Iwan Doull, who co-heads the team with Parker, has a mastery of many types of litigation, including in the insurance sector, where his work for After the event (ATE) insurance providers continues to gain national recognition.

Practice head(s):

Nick Parker; Iwan Doull


Other key lawyers:

Harry Moyle; Lauren Parsons


Testimonials

‘They display strong commercial acumen, excellent client care and excellent analytical skills.’

‘Nick Parker provides excellent commercial advice and has a hands on approach. His lightness of touch belies an incredible ability to give pragmatic, incisive and robust advice.’

‘Iwan Doull is a fine mediation advocate, with the right balance of being robust yet reasonable.’

Key clients

Connolly and Callaghan Ltd


Barry Radley


Weldec Ltd


Mr Tajinder Sall and Mr Bhupinder Sall


Welsh Government


ARAG Plc


Brit Insurance


Plaid Cymru (the Party of Wales)


The Involve Group of Companies


Activequote Limited


Work highlights


  • Successfully acted for Connolly and Callaghan Ltd, a large development company based in Bristol, in a multimillion-pound shareholder dispute with its former development partner.
  • Successfully represented Wales’ largest comprehensive school, Whitchurch High School, at a trial in the High Court in a claim against a travel company relating to cancellation of ski trips during the Covid lockdown period.
  • Acting for one of UK largest independent recruitment consultants, Involve Recruitment, in a dispute with one of its former directors relating to breaches of confidentiality and restrictive covenants.

Harding Evans LLP

Based in Newport but by no means restricted to handling purely parochial cases, the 'approachable, friendly and responsive' team at Harding Evans LLP punches well above its weight and provides a 'first-class service' to individuals, SMEs and larger corporates, including on matters which have national ramifications. This has been exemplified by being a party in several reported cases in recent years, including a precedent setting case dealing with commercial landlord and tenant disputes. 'Outstanding' team head Ben Jenkins led on the aforementioned matter and is appreciated by clients for his 'commercially aware' advice across a range of commercial litigation matters, as well as having niche expertise in defamation law. 'Very astute' associate William Watkins also regularly assists Jenkins on large-scale disputes, as well as having his own caseload, including as it relates to debt recovery matters - an area that he also benefits from his qualification as a high court bailiff.

Practice head(s):

Ben Jenkins


Other key lawyers:

William Watkins


Testimonials

The approachable, friendly and responsive team provides a first-class service.’

The practice has a diverse range of people and I have always felt that they have my best interests at heart.’

‘They are very commercial and dedicated to getting the best results.’

Key clients

Mr Sam Warburton


Euro Foods Group


Water Treatment Products Limited


The London Trading Company (UK) Ltd


The Vale of Glamorgan Hotel Limited T/A The Vale Resort


BOGOD Group


Pobl Group


NAAFI


Wet and Forget Limited


Menzies LLP


Landmark Entertainment Limited


Number One Property Management Limited


Leekes Limited


Arvans Civil Engineering Limited


Hughes Forrest Limited


Euro Foods Group


Bottlers & Distillers (Wales) Limited T/A Hensol Castle Distillery


Pantanas Care Centre


Polar Cooling Services Limited


Jencap Partners Limited


Bond Demolition Limited


The Care Collective


Work highlights


  • Advised a food and drink supplier (Euro Foods Limited) in preventing a potential £10m loss.
  • Obtaining a judgment of over £1million in complex commercial litigation and enforcing on behalf of our client Water Treatment Products Limited.
  • Assisting a client in a multimillion-pound partnership dispute.

JCP Solicitors

Leveraging robust ties with local businesses, as well as generating a significant amount of referral work from regional professional services firms, well-established Swansea-based firm JCP Solicitors is seen with considerable regularity acting for clients as defendants and claimants across a myriad corporate/commercial disputes, including as it relates to shareholder/partnership litigation. Andrew Meech is engaged in much of this work, although his longstanding relationship with Italian sportswear manufacturer Macron has also led to increased traction among other northern European clients, in particular. David Owen is also a key member of the team with debt recovery (for lender clients) and contentious insolvency matters core areas of focus.

Practice head(s):

Andrew Meech; Sophie Thomas


Other key lawyers:

David Owen


Testimonials

‘The JCP team is fantastic. The lawyers are hard working, client focused and a great option for those looking for truly personalised service, from solicitors who really care about them and will fight their corner.’

Andrew Meech is always available and provides advice that is, from a legal standpoint, exactly what I require.’

Key clients

Macron SPA


Macron Sportswear UK Limited


Burns Pet Nutrition


Front Runner Events


Work highlights


Red Kite Law LLP

The 'strong and dynamic' team at Red Kite Law LLP continues to gain market share on behalf of corporates, individuals and SMEs, which are appreciative of the 'cost-effective' and 'highly commercial' advice it provides across a myriad commercial litigation, including shareholder disputes and issues relating to fraud and deceit. Much of the success for the firm's increased visibility in the space can be attributed to the stellar efforts of Rhian Davies who provides 'very effective leadership', and is 'dynamic, practical and commercial in her approach', skilled as she is at handling full-blown disputes as well as being appreciative of the importance of strategic advice at a pre-action stage to minimise costs and to prevent a matter from unnecessarily mushrooming out of control. Davies also regularly handles work for Welsh higher education providers through the firm's NPS panel appointment. Steven Koukos  is another a key member of the team and is recognised as a 'genuine all round gem' with proficiency across a range of 'commercial dispute resolution from company to property and commercial matters'. 

Practice head(s):

Rhian Davies


Other key lawyers:

Steven Koukos


Testimonials

A strong and dynamic team with good commercial acumen.’

The firm picks matters up at very short notice and provide advice in a clear, concise and positive manner.’

Rhian Davies has terrific commercial awareness, a calming and assured presence with clients, and a highly effective communication style which is intelligent and direct. She is assertive when the situation demands it and clients love her.’

Key clients

Milford Haven Port Authority


Castell Howell Foods Limited


Phoenix Legal Services Limited


Valero Energy


Swansea University


Neal Remediation Limited


Bexmoor Limited


Work highlights


  • Advising a company and group of shareholders in relation to a shareholder dispute.
  • Advising a company in relation to a fraud and deceit claim against ex-employees.
  • Advising a company in relation to a breach of a commercial agreement. The dispute also involves elements of Swiss law and cross-border jurisdiction.

Dolmans

Leveraging its public sector ties, developed chiefly as a result of the firm's market-leading health and safety, and defendant personal injury practices, Dolmans also handles some more conventional commercial litigation for many of the same for local authority clients. The firm also represents private sector companies in breach of contract claims through their insurers, as well as advising insurers on coverage issues. The team is led by Peter Bennett.

Practice head(s):

Peter Bennett


Other key lawyers:

Philip Bradley; Simon Evans; Claire Thomas


Key clients

Dauson Group


AXA XL Insurance Limited


Kudos Liability Adjusters


Ageas Insurance


Work highlights


  • Advised a Local Authority in regard to pending litigation concerning diminution in value allegedly caused to a property consequent upon flooding incidents taking place at the property due to defective drainage infrastructure and representing a proliferation of issues from simply claim for the cost of repair in such claims, to a loss of value in the property itself.
  • Advising a Local Authority in regard to allegedly negligent replies provided in a local land charges search and the implications thereof in terms of alleged losses by reason of the purchase of contaminated land.

Gomer Williams & Co

The 'responsive and helpful' team at Gomer Williams & Co provides 'clear and precise advice' to a loyal and growing base of individuals and businesses throughout south Wales. Team head Clare Tregoning is 'knowledgeable in all matters relating to commercial litigation', including as it relates to contract disputes, as well as contentious property and IP matters.

Practice head(s):

Clare Tregoning


Testimonials

The responsive and helpful team provides clear and precise advice.’

‘Clare Tregoning is knowledgeable in all matters relating to commercial litigation and provides very professional advice.’

Key clients

Kevin Green


Pushpinder and Catherine Mangat


Mallaghan


Create FM Limited


Swansea Council


Diana Mingaile


Stradey Park Hotel


James Lilley


Phoenix Music Ltd


Christopher Watts


Eugene Heanue


Work highlights


  • Advising a private company in relation to claims of defamation, malicious falsehood and conversion. The client argues conversion on the basis of withheld sums due to them under client fee arrangements assigned to the client within the administration of a separate entity.
  • Representing a group action regarding the highly contested Stradey Park Hotel following service of an application seeking injunctive relief. The application concerned a right of way which benefitted the clients; the application was dismissed and an adverse costs order was made against the applicant.
  • Advising Swansea Council in relation to a public right of way dispute arising from the leasing of recreation land for purpose of providing a playing field.

Harrison Clark Rickerbys

Now with two experienced partners in its ranks following Wayne Beynon's arrival in 2023, Harrison Clark Rickerbys has greater strength-in-depth with which to service existing and standalone clients which are instructing the team across a broad swathe of commercial litigation assignments. Beynon's core focus remains on handling IP-related disputes, complementing co-head Hefin Archer-Williams ' strength at handling corporate and shareholder matters, where he is noted for his ability to look 'at the bigger commercial picture as well as the legal issues in the dispute'. 

Practice head(s):

Hefin Archer-Williams; Wayne Beynon


Testimonials

‘The responsive team provides focused and commercially sound advice.’

‘Hefin Archer-Williams is client focused, friendly and gives excellent advice. He looks at the bigger commercial picture as well as the legal issues in the dispute.’

‘Hefin Archer-Williams is a very experienced litigator who calmly deals with heavy litigation. He is not phased by aggressive moves by opposing firms and provides sensible straightforward advice.’

Work highlights


RDP Law

Newport-based firm RDP Law handles a range of commercial litigation work for South Wales-based SMEs, partnerships and individuals, working alongside the firm’s corporate and real estate departments, if required. As well as handling an increasing volume of minority shareholder disputes, the firm also regularly handles litigation for local property developers and is adept at resolving matters utilising ADR methods, if necessary. Although she is best known for her property litigation expertise, Sarah Porter also handles some broader civil litigation in her role as team head.

Practice head(s):

Sarah Porter


Other key lawyers:

Robert Davies; Liz O’Connor


Testimonials

The whole team at RDP is phenomenal, they are incredibly professional with their approach.’

‘The team is small and therefore efficient, insofar as each team member is fully engaged in their cases.’

Robert Davies is excellent.’

Work highlights


Robertson Solicitors

At well-established Cardiff-based firm Robertson Solicitors, 'extremely conscientious and hardworking' litigation head William Baird  has a strong reputation advising clients across a range of commercial litigation, including shareholder disputes. He is praised for his 'excellent judgement' and willingness to 'go the extra mile'. 

Practice head(s):

Luke Hallinan; William Baird


Testimonials

‘The solicitors are personable, approachable, hard-working, conscientious and reliable.’

‘Exceptional client care. Realistic approach to dispute resolution, client focused.’

‘This firm has a very hands on approach, working and communicating closely with clients to ensure they are informed every step of the way.’

Work highlights