CLM Bitai & Partners | View firm profile
- DEFINING COMPETITION LAW
Competition law, despite its extensive historical roots dating back to the late 19th century, remains a relatively underappreciated legal discipline. Given its broad regulatory scope, it is imperative to establish a precise understanding of its framework. In essence, competition law can be defined as follows: A branch of economic law that contains rules related to the protection of economic competition and the prevention of harm to consumers. Its aim is to control and maintain economic competition, which is the basis of the market economy. Its two main areas are the law against unfair competition and the law of restrictions of competition.
If competition law governs fair economic competition and consumer protection, why is it still not widely recognized among economic operators, corporate entities, and executives? Every business inherently operates within the realm of economic competition, as companies manufacture, produce, and distribute products and services. Nevertheless, competition law imposes a variety of prohibitions on corporate conduct, with penalties in Hungary for violations potentially reaching up to 13% of the net turnover of the company or corporate group from the preceding fiscal year. However, in light of an emergency decree, this penalty has been temporarily increased to 15%.
Despite its extensive reach, competition law remains an area of limited familiarity for many corporate actors. For legal professionals, this is precisely where the strategic approach and project management elements come into play.
- COMPETITION LAW AS A LEGAL PROJECT
At what point does a company or its leadership encounter competition law?
In adverse circumstances, when the Hungarian Competition Authority initiates proceedings due to alleged anti-competitive agreements, such as restrictive trade practices or abuse of a dominant position. This may involve formal notices or even unannounced inspections (dawn raids).
Conversely, in an optimal scenario, corporate management proactively acknowledges the significance of competition law, assesses potential risks, and implements a competition compliance program to ensure regulatory adherence and mitigate exposure to sanctions.
Regardless of whether the issue is a reactive legal defence or proactive risk mitigation, each scenario necessitates strategic legal intervention. At this stage, competition law becomes a structured legal project, requiring a lawyer adept in legal project management, in addition to possessing technical legal expertise.
- ESTABLISHING A COMPLIANCE FRAMEWORK
The most cost-effective and operationally efficient approach to competition law compliance is to implement preventive measures ensuring adherence to competition regulations. Competition law establishes substantive prohibitions concerning anti-competitive agreements and the abuse of market dominance, necessitating a comprehensive understanding of both EU and Hungarian legal frameworks.
For this reason, involving a lawyer specializing in competition law is essential. Their role extends beyond a mere contractual review; it encompasses an in-depth analysis of corporate operations, including sales structures, marketing strategies, and franchise agreements. This process demands coordination with company leadership and key internal stakeholders.
A thorough compliance audit includes assessing verbal agreements, coordinated practices, and tacit understandings between competitors and business partners, even where no formal documentation exists. Additionally, corporate affiliations with industry associations, representation within such organizations, and the subjects of discussions in these forums must be scrutinized.
Successful compliance necessitates unwavering commitment from corporate leadership and the active engagement of all relevant business units. The outcome of the compliance review is a tailored regulatory framework comprising policies governing interactions with competitors, business associates, and franchise partners, along with internal corporate guidelines and employee training programs.
For effective implementation, employees must acknowledge the new internal policy and participate in structured training programs. If compliance obligations are incorporated into employment contracts, violations may lead to employment-related sanctions. This intricate compliance mechanism demands the continuous oversight of a legal expert responsible for implementation, monitoring, and enforcement.
- RESPONDING TO A COMPETITION AUTHORITY INVESTIGATION
When the Hungarian Competition Authority initiates proceedings, the affected company first receives an official request for data provision. Given that the investigation serves the broader objective of protecting market competition, the Authority conducts a comprehensive background analysis, requiring extensive documentation on the company’s operations, market position, competitor relations, business partnerships, and organizational structure.
Compiling accurate and exhaustive responses entails significant effort and necessitates input from multiple departments, including executive management, sales, marketing, and finance.
At this juncture, the lawyer assumes the role of project manager. The initial task is to provide the company with a clear understanding of competition law principles, explaining what constitutes an infringement, the importance of regulatory cooperation, and the potential legal repercussions. One of the most complex challenges lies in briefing executives unfamiliar with competition law and impressing upon them the gravity of regulatory scrutiny.
Subsequently, a legal strategy must be formulated. The process commences with an internal investigation to ascertain whether a violation has occurred. If a breach is identified, the lawyer must determine the scope of the infringement, the timeframe involved, the business units affected, and the corporate officers responsible, as well as assess its impact on competitors and business partners.
If the Hungarian Competition Authority possesses prima facie evidence of an infringement, document reconstruction becomes a critical priority. This often requires collaboration with IT professionals to conduct forensic keyword searches across corporate records.
The subsequent legal strategy depends on whether the company has indeed violated competition law. If an infraction is confirmed, a legal risk assessment follows, including market definition, market share estimation, analysis of impacted business activities, and calculation of the potential financial penalty based on the Authority’s guidelines. While the precise fine amount is difficult to predict, mitigating measures—including participation in a leniency program, settlement negotiations, or the introduction of a compliance program—can significantly reduce sanctions.
Additionally, legal counsel is essential in determining whether to challenge the Authority’s findings through litigation or to seek immediate legal remedies. These decisions involve a balance of legal, business, and financial considerations, making the lawyer’s strategic coordination role indispensable. Given that such proceedings may extend over several years, meticulous legal management is crucial.
- LEGAL PROJECT MANAGEMENT IN COMPETITION LAW
As previously discussed in legal project management contexts, clients increasingly expect a structured, efficient, and predictable legal service model. In addition to overseeing competition law compliance for corporate clients, law firms must ensure their own internal project execution adheres to professional standards. This includes timely completion of assigned tasks within defined budgets.
Where engagements are not structured as fixed-fee arrangements, clients still demand precise estimates of billable hours or, increasingly, fee caps to mitigate cost uncertainties. Managing legal resources effectively and transparently is as critical as delivering substantive expertise in competition law advisory services.